DO NOT Buy Amazon Potty Training Pants Until You See This Test
By Karissa GelownUpdated Nov 2026
Same water. Same pour. Watch the outside.
Parents ask us one question more than any other: “Why are yours $21 when Amazon has training pants for $10?”
Fair question. They look the same in the photos. So I bought the three most popular cheap packs, tried each one on a toddler for a week, and poured a full accident into every single pair.
Two soaked straight through. One was so padded it worked like a diaper. Only one pair passed. Here’s exactly what happened.
3 Cheap Packs vs Ours
I went for the three every mom finds first: the bestseller, the “extra padded” one, and the cheapest multipack. Then ours. Same water, same pour, same toddler.
The Amazon bestseller
The listing said“Absorbent. Leak-proof. Soft cotton.”
What happenedOne pour, then a paper towel pressed on the outside. It came up soaked. On a toddler, that’s down her legs, into her socks and across the kitchen floor.
The “extra padded” one
The listing said“Extra thick padding for maximum absorbency.”
What happenedSo much padding it soaks everything away from her skin, just like a diaper. She peed, felt nothing and kept playing. No feeling, no learning.
The cheapest multipack
The listing said“Value pack. Reusable. Machine washable.”
What happenedHalf a glass of water ran straight through my fingers. There’s barely anything in the middle to catch it.
Three cheap packs. Same result: back in diapers.
Then I ran the same test on ours.
UpAiry
What we promise“They feel it. It stays in. 112ml without a leak.”
What happenedSame water, same test. Everything stayed inside the pants and the outside stayed dry. She’d still feel it, but your floor never would.
They Look The Same. They’re Not.
They might look the same. They might feel the same. They might even let your toddler feel wet just the same.
The difference is what’s inside. Most cheap pairs are one thin layer of cotton with a bit of padding sewn in. UpAiry is built in layers, and each one has a job.
112ml Holds a full toddler accident without leaking
Only one holds it.
It’s Not Just Us
Scroll the 1-star reviews on the cheap packs and you’ll read the same story over and over. Leaked. Soaked through. Dripping down their legs. Waste of money.
Show 3 more reviews
Real 1 and 2-star reviews of low-cost training pants on Amazon. Reviewer names blurred.
Why One Leak Puts Them Back In Diapers
Feeling wet is how they learn. Pee = wet. Wet = yuck. That connection is the whole lesson, and it’s why the cheap ones can work for a day or two.
But if every accident runs down their legs, you’re cleaning up puddles five times a day. You’re stressed. They’re upset. And sooner or later you grab the diapers “just for today.”
That’s the moment training stops. Not because your toddler isn’t ready. Because the pants couldn’t hold it.
Side By Side
So Why Are Ours $21?
Honest answer: $21 is the price of one pair on its own, and hardly anyone buys just one. Here’s what a pair actually costs:
And the cheap pack isn’t the cheap option. It’s the one you buy twice: once for the undies, then again for up to $100 a month of diapers when you go back to them.
If UpAiry doesn’t get them out of diapers in 75 days, you get every cent back. You don’t even have to send them back.
Get Up To 6 Pairs FreeThe 14 Days After We Switched
Same toddler, same week of chaos. The only thing I changed was what she was wearing.
- Day 2
“Mommy, I’m wet.”
She looked down and said it. She’d never once said that in a diaper. Only this time there was no puddle.
- Day 6
Telling me every time
She started telling me before, not after. She even took herself to the potty.
92%of parents noticed progress in the first week.* - Day 11
Most of the time
Making it to the potty most of the time. The odd accident, and every one stayed in the pants.
93%of parents noticed fewer accidents.* - Day 14
Out of diapers
Using the potty on her own, no reminders. The diaper pack in the cupboard stopped going down.
99%of parents saw a positive impact on potty training.*
Parents Are Warning Each Other
Parents keep leaving the same warning on the cheap packs, so the next mom doesn’t make the same mistake.
What Parents Say After Switching
★★★★★“These work!! We started using them and now my son is using the potty. I honestly thought this day would never come...”
Lauren D.
★★★★★“I got 5 of the giraffe training pants for my daughter. She wore them to daycare with spares and the staff were pleased the accidents were contained. Now in her second week she has no more accidents and feels proud of herself! Absolutely love these.”
Sophie L.
★★★★★“Excellent quality and my son loves the patterns! Good absorbency while still letting him feel his pee. He is now using the potty! Will definitely buy again.”
Emily R.
★★★★★“My little one had her first accident in these and I'm impressed by the absorbency, the outside stayed dry. The adorable colours and patterns made potty training much more enjoyable!”
Hannah W.
★★★★★“Amazing product! We saw a difference in only three days of using it.”
Danielle K.